When comparing Medicare Supplement Plan G and Plan N, one of the biggest differences people hear about is Medicare Part B excess charges.
Many brokers use excess charges as a major reason to recommend Plan G over Plan N.
But how important are excess charges in the real world?
For many Medicare beneficiaries — especially in Pennsylvania — the answer may surprise you.
What Are Medicare Part B Excess Charges?
Medicare Part B excess charges can occur when a doctor does not accept Medicare assignment.
In those cases, the provider may legally bill up to 15% above the Medicare-approved amount for covered services.
This additional amount is called an excess charge.
The Main Difference Between Plan G and Plan N
Both Plan G and Plan N provide strong Medicare Supplement coverage.
However:
| Feature | Plan G | Plan N |
|---|---|---|
| Covers Part B excess charges | Yes | No |
| Monthly premium | Higher | Lower |
| Office visit copays | None | Small copays may apply |
| Emergency room copays | None | Possible copay if not admitted |
For many people, the excess charge issue becomes the deciding factor between the two plans.
How Common Are Excess Charges?
This is where things become very important.
In reality, many doctors throughout the United States accept Medicare assignment.
That means:
- they agree to Medicare’s approved payment rates
- they do not bill excess charges
As a result, many Medicare beneficiaries may never encounter excess charges at all.
In Pennsylvania, excess charges are often far less common than many people assume.
Why Some Brokers Push Plan G
Plan G is an excellent plan.
It offers very predictable coverage and eliminates concern about excess charges.
However, some people automatically choose Plan G without fully comparing the long-term premium difference between Plan G and Plan N.
Over time, that premium difference can become substantial.
For healthy Medicare beneficiaries who rarely visit doctors, Plan N may potentially provide meaningful savings even if occasional copays occur.
Real-World Perspective on Excess Charges
After helping Medicare beneficiaries for decades, one thing becomes clear:
Many people become far more concerned about excess charges than they probably need to be.
That does not mean excess charges never happen.
They can.
But for many Medicare beneficiaries:
- the actual frequency may be low
- the potential savings from lower Plan N premiums may outweigh the risk
This is especially true when:
- doctors already accept Medicare assignment
- beneficiaries verify providers beforehand
- healthcare usage is relatively moderate
Plan N Often Appeals to Cost-Conscious Medicare Beneficiaries
Many people choosing Plan N are looking for:
- lower monthly premiums
- long-term value
- protection from major medical bills
- flexibility with Original Medicare
In many cases, beneficiaries are comfortable accepting:
- small office visit copays
- the possibility of excess charges
in exchange for premium savings.
When Plan G May Still Make Sense
Plan G may still be attractive for people who:
- want the most predictable coverage possible
- strongly dislike any out-of-pocket surprises
- see specialists frequently
- travel extensively
- simply prefer maximum simplicity
For some Medicare beneficiaries, the peace of mind alone is worth the higher premium.
Excess Charges Are Only One Piece of the Puzzle
Choosing between Plan G and Plan N should involve more than just excess charges.
Other factors matter too:
- premium differences
- future rate increase potential
- healthcare usage
- physician preferences
- long-term affordability
A lower premium today may or may not remain the better value over time.
Pennsylvania Medicare Beneficiaries Should Compare Carefully
Medicare Supplement pricing can vary significantly depending on:
- age
- zip code
- carrier
- household discounts
- underwriting status
That’s why comparing plans carefully is important.
For many Pennsylvania Medicare beneficiaries, Plan N can offer a strong balance between coverage and cost.
Frequently Asked Questions About Plan G and Plan N Excess Charges
Does Plan N cover excess charges?
No. Medicare Supplement Plan N does not cover Medicare Part B excess charges.
Does Plan G cover excess charges?
Yes. Plan G covers Medicare Part B excess charges.
Are excess charges common in Pennsylvania?
Many doctors in Pennsylvania accept Medicare assignment, which may reduce the likelihood of excess charges occurring.
Is Plan N worth the risk?
For many healthy Medicare beneficiaries, the premium savings from Plan N may outweigh the potential risk of occasional excess charges.
Can I ask my doctor if they accept Medicare assignment?
Yes. Medicare beneficiaries can ask providers directly whether they accept Medicare assignment.
Final Thoughts
Plan G and Plan N are both strong Medicare Supplement options.
The right choice often depends on:
- comfort level
- healthcare usage
- premium sensitivity
- long-term financial goals
While excess charges are an important consideration, many Medicare beneficiaries may discover that the issue is less significant in real-world practice than they initially feared.
For that reason, Plan N continues to grow in popularity among Medicare beneficiaries looking for strong coverage with lower monthly premiums.
For more information, please call 215-967-8828 or email Joe@MyMedicareQuotes.com
Click here to send us a message!
