Humana Achieve vs. Humana Medicare Supplement

Compare premiums, standardized benefits and SilverSneakers availability to determine which Humana Medicare Supplement option may provide the better overall value.

When comparing Humana Achieve with Humana’s standard Medicare Supplement options, it is important to consider more than the monthly premium.

Humana is often among the more competitively priced Medicare Supplement companies we compare in Pennsylvania. However, rates vary by applicant, location, plan letter and available discounts, so no single company is always the lowest-priced choice for everyone.

Humana Achieve is generally positioned as a lower-premium option, while certain standard Humana Medicare Supplement policies may include SilverSneakers. Because the medical benefits are standardized when comparing the same plan letter, the decision frequently comes down to premium, available discounts and whether the applicant will use the additional fitness benefit.

Excellent
DeAngelis Agency5.0
Based on 167 reviews
Kevin McCoy
2 days ago
Jim walked me through every detail of the process. I was not good at doing things on line or understanding the terms. Jim took the time to explain what I needed and how to get it done.
Response from the owner:Kevin, thank you for your review. I’m glad I was able to help you with your Medicare Supplement Plan. Please reach out with any questions.
Kelly Simonson
7 days ago
Experienced and very knowledgable agent. He is awesome!
Response from the owner:Kelly, thanks so much for your review. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.
Joseph really helped me navigate getting set-up with Medicare and applying for the other supplements I needed.
Response from the owner:Christina, thank you so much for your review. It was a pleasure to work with you on your Medicare Supplement plan. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.
Debby P
1 week ago
Made a stressful process smooth and seamless. Very responsive throughout.
Response from the owner:Thank you Debby! I’m glad I could make the process smooth and take some of the stress out of it. I really appreciate you taking the time to leave a review. It was a pleasure working with you.
Ann Hook
2 weeks ago
Joe was a god-send! He walked me through a very intimidating maize with his impressive knowledge and expertise. I called him multiple times with many different scenario questions. He welcomed my calls and never made me feel like I was a bother. I feel very confident that I made the right choice with Joe, and you will too!
Response from the owner:Ann, thank you so much for your wonderful review. I’m glad I could make the Medicare process less intimidating and help you feel confident in your decision. Your questions were never a bother—it was truly a pleasure working with you. Please don’t hesitate to call anytime you need help.
heidi donaldson
2 weeks ago
Mr. DeAngelis was a Godsend in aiding my way through the Medicare system. I felt so relieved knowing with his knowledge and many years of experience, the correct decisions were made. I highly recommend Mr. DeAngelis.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much, Heidi. I’m glad I could make the Medicare process easier and help you feel confident in your decisions. I truly appreciate your kind words and recommendation!
Michele Mcquoid
2 weeks ago
My father needed Medicare supplement part b and Joe was such a big help. He spent alot of time with us to find the correct plan for our needs. If u need help definitely give Joe a call. I will be recommending him to all my friends and family.
Response from the owner:Michele, thank you so much for your wonderful review and recommendation. It was a pleasure helping you and your father find Medicare Supplement coverage that fit his needs. Please don’t hesitate to reach out if either of you has any questions in the future.
Susan Baatz
1 month ago
I came across Joe from a postcard that he had mailed out. I am new to Medicare and found him very helpful and knowledgeable. He was able to explain differences in plans and options for my particular needs. I would highly recommend him to anyone that’s transitioning to Medicare.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for your review Susan. I appreciate your recommendation. If you have any questions or concerns about your Medicare Supplement plan, please reach out.
Andrea Vandeven
1 month ago
I used Joe DeAngelis to help me enroll in Medicare, and he made the entire process simple, quick, and stress-free. He provided objective advice and recommended coverage that best fit my healthcare needs while keeping my costs as low as possible. I truly appreciated his knowledge, professionalism, and straightforward guidance. I highly recommend Joe to anyone looking for help navigating Medicare.
Response from the owner:Andrea, thank you so much for your review. It was a pleasure to work with you on your Medicare Supplement Plan selection. Please reach out with any questionsor concerns.
Noreen Gilbert
2 months ago
Joe is so incredibly helpful. His demeanor is plesant. No mattter what questions we have he goes above and beyond to help! Customer Services is impeccable!
Response from the owner:Noreen, thank you so much for your review. It's always a pleasure speaking with you. Please reach out with any questions or concerns about your Medicare Supplement Plan.
Jennifer Leal
2 months ago
Joe was incredibly helpful and helped clarify the Medicare plans/process better than anyone I had spoken to before. He was patient with my questions and helped complete the application easily over a call. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for help regarding Medicare.
Response from the owner:Jennifer, thank you so much for your review and trusting me with your father's Medicare Supplement coverage. If you have any questions or concerns, please reach out..
Lisa Frushone
2 months ago
Amazing !!I can’t recommend Joe high enough! He handled everything and made this experience stressless and personal which was meaningful to be with an extremely busy schedule!
Response from the owner:Lisa, thank you for your wonderful review and trusting me with your Medicare supplement insurance coverage. I'm glad I was able to make the process simple and easy for you. If you ever have any questions or concerns, please reach out.
Joseph Verhey
3 months ago
Above and beyond service. Don’t go anywhere else. Joe is the guy who makes “I’ve got a guy!” saying come to life. It was like talking to an old friend who cares. Thanks Joe.
Response from the owner:Joe, thank you so much for your review. I really enjoyed our conversation and I'm glad I was able to assist you with your Medicare Supplement Plan selection. If you have any questions or concerns, please reach out!
Nancy Poinsett
3 months ago
Joe made the medicare process easy and understandable. I highly recommend using him for your medicare insurance needs.
Response from the owner:Thank you, Nancy, for your kind review and for trusting me with your Medicare coverage. It was a pleasure helping you, and I truly appreciate the opportunity to work with both you and Keith. Thank you for your recommendation.
Richard Jaynes
4 months ago
I contacted Joe DeAngelis for Medicare assistance, and he answered all my questions and guided me with some steps I was not aware. Joe was super friendly and easy to talk to. I was totally satisfied with Joe and appreciative how he wanted all my questions answered and he made himself available for any future questions. Call Joe if you want a pleasant experience!! He is the best! Rich J.
Response from the owner:Rich, thank you so much for your review. I was happy to help you with your Medicare Supplement Plan selection. If you should have any questions or concerns, please reach out.
ivan doner
4 months ago
Response from the owner:Thank you for your review, Ivan. It was a pleasure to meet with you and Chris. Please reach out with any questions.
Christine Doner
4 months ago
Excellent presentation! Great customer service!
Response from the owner:Thank you for your review, Chris. It was a pleasure to meet with you and Ivan. Please reach out with any questions.
Colette Spera
4 months ago
Joe is 5 stars * * * * * hands down. He is polite, knowledgeable and extremely efficient in explaining the entire Medicare experience for me. It's was a bonus that we went to high school together and lived down the street from one another. I highly recommend him to anyone navigating a new "turning of 65" and applying for Medicare coverage. A+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for you most excellent review, Colette. It was a pleasure catching up with a High School mate after all these years. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.
Rick Bott
4 months ago
Ver easy to work with; the easiest part of the process was talking to Joe. He got me all set in 30 minutes. Highly recommend.
Response from the owner:Rick, thank you so much for your review! It was great to work on your Medicare Supplement Plan selection. If you have any questions about your Plan N Medicare Supplement Plan, please reach out.
Lisa Hartman
5 months ago
Joe was great! Happy to have him as my insurance broker
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for your review, Lisa! It was a pleasure to work with you on your Medicare Supplement Plan enrollment. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.
john schmidtberger
5 months ago
Friendly, helpful, knowledgeable. Easy to reach. Helped me out when I hit a tech problem with a third-party application!
Response from the owner:John, it was a pleasure helping you with your Medicare Supplement coverage and I'm glad to hear it was easy for you. If you have any questions or concerns, please reach out.
Passing Through
6 months ago
Good morning everyone. want to give special thanks to Joe he is a godsend, for those who have reached golden age helping people navigate their way through signing up for Medicare and making the right choices that fit your need for supplements for part B . so I hope that anyone needs a Medicare advisor Definitely consider Joe for his kind patience and knowledge Sincerely Robert & Brenda
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for your review Brenda. It was a pleasure working on your Medicare Supplement plan with you. Please reach out if you have any questions or concerns.
Floss Hauschild
6 months ago
Can't believe how shell-shocked and overwhelmed I felt when trying to navigate my way through the Medicare sign-up process. Thank goodness for people like Joe, who are infomative and intellegent enough to lend a hand and help people like myself figure all this out! I was evaluated and directed to plans that meet my personal needs Thanks Joe for all you do. You saved me major agita!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for your excellent review, Floss. I'm glad I was able to save you from "major agita"! 🙂 It was a pleasure working with you on your Medicare Supplement Plan. If you should have any questions moving forward, please reach out.
Robert DiMatteo
7 months ago
Easy going and very helpful. Joe made the whole process less nerve wracking overall. I would highly recommend him to anyone turning 65 and wondering what to do about all of this.
Response from the owner:Thank you for your review, Robert. Please reach out if you have any questions or concerns about your Medicare Supplement Plan.
Fred Kaissi
8 months ago
Joe DeAngelis is friendly, attentive, and very knowledgeable. He takes the time to explain Medicare in a clear, easy-to-understand way. I really appreciate his guidance and would recommend him to anyone.
Response from the owner:Thank you for your review, Fred. Please reach out if you have any questions or concerns about your Medicare Supplement Plan

What Is Humana Achieve?

Humana Achieve is a Medicare Supplement insurance policy offered by Humana. It works alongside Original Medicare and helps pay certain Medicare-approved out-of-pocket costs according to the Medicare Supplement plan selected.

Depending on availability and applicant eligibility, Humana Achieve may offer:

  • Competitive Medicare Supplement premiums
  • Standardized Medicare Supplement benefits
  • No traditional provider network
  • Coverage anywhere in the United States where Medicare is accepted
  • A household discount for eligible applicants

Humana Achieve generally does not include the SilverSneakers fitness benefit. Applicants should confirm all policy features before enrolling because availability and additional services can vary.

What Is Humana’s Standard Medicare Supplement Option?

Humana may also offer a standard Medicare Supplement product that includes additional services such as SilverSneakers.

When comparing the same Medicare Supplement plan letter, the required medical benefits are standardized. For example, Humana Achieve Plan N and a standard Humana Medicare Supplement Plan N provide the same standardized Plan N medical benefits.

The differences may include:

  • The monthly premium
  • Available household discounts
  • SilverSneakers eligibility
  • Other noninsurance services
  • The Humana underwriting company issuing the policy

Are Humana Medicare Supplement Rates Competitive?

Humana is frequently among the more competitively priced Medicare Supplement companies available to Pennsylvania applicants. This can make both Humana Achieve and Humana’s standard Medicare Supplement options worth considering.

However, Medicare Supplement rates are personalized. The company offering the lowest premium for one person may not offer the lowest premium for someone of a different age, gender, ZIP code or household situation.

Our approach: The DeAngelis Agency compares Humana with other Medicare Supplement companies rather than assuming that one carrier will always provide the best value. The goal is to find an appropriate combination of competitive pricing, benefits and long-term value for each applicant.

Humana Achieve vs. Standard Humana Medicare Supplement

Feature Humana Achieve Standard Humana Supplement
Medicare Supplement coverage Standardized according to the selected plan letter Standardized according to the selected plan letter
Premium positioning Generally positioned as a lower-premium Humana option May have a different or higher premium
SilverSneakers Generally not included May be included with certain policies
Doctor network No traditional provider network No traditional provider network
Best suited for Someone focused primarily on the insurance premium Someone who may use the available fitness benefit

Does Humana Achieve Include SilverSneakers?

Humana Achieve generally does not include SilverSneakers. Someone who selects Humana Achieve and wants to use a local gym may therefore need to purchase a fitness membership separately.

This additional expense should be considered when comparing Humana Achieve with another Humana Medicare Supplement policy that may include SilverSneakers.

Do Other Humana Medicare Supplement Policies Include SilverSneakers?

Certain standard Humana Medicare Supplement policies may include SilverSneakers. The program can provide access to participating fitness centers, exercise classes, online workouts and other fitness resources.

SilverSneakers availability should always be confirmed for the specific policy before enrolling. It is also important to verify that the fitness center an applicant plans to use participates in the program.

Could the Plan With SilverSneakers Provide Better Overall Value?

The Medicare Supplement policy with the lowest premium is not necessarily the option with the lowest total monthly cost.

Someone who does not use a fitness center may prefer the potentially lower premium available through Humana Achieve. Someone who regularly pays for a participating gym may find that a Humana Medicare Supplement policy with SilverSneakers provides better overall value, even when its insurance premium is somewhat higher.

The comparison should include:

  • The Medicare Supplement premium
  • Available household discounts
  • Whether SilverSneakers is included
  • Whether the applicant’s preferred gym participates
  • The cost of any fitness membership the applicant would otherwise purchase

The right choice depends on the applicant’s rates and whether the additional fitness benefit will actually be used.

Are the Medical Benefits the Same?

Medicare Supplement plans are standardized by plan letter. A Plan G provides the standardized Plan G benefits, and a Plan N provides the standardized Plan N benefits, regardless of which insurance company issues the policy.

Therefore, when comparing Humana Achieve with Humana’s standard Medicare Supplement product, the core medical benefits are the same when the same plan letter is being compared.

SilverSneakers is an additional service. It does not change the standardized medical benefits provided by the Medicare Supplement policy.

When Humana Achieve May Be the Better Choice

Humana Achieve may provide the better value when:

  • You want a potentially lower Humana premium
  • You do not regularly use a gym
  • You exercise at home
  • You already have an inexpensive fitness membership
  • Your preferred gym does not participate in SilverSneakers
  • You are unlikely to use additional fitness benefits

There is little reason to pay more for a benefit you do not expect to use.

When SilverSneakers May Provide Better Value

A Humana Medicare Supplement option with SilverSneakers may be more attractive when:

  • You regularly use a gym
  • Your preferred fitness center accepts SilverSneakers
  • You currently pay separately for a fitness membership
  • You want access to participating locations while traveling
  • You intend to use available classes or online fitness resources

The important question is whether you will actually use the additional benefit.

Why Humana Medicare Supplement Premiums Vary

Medicare Supplement premiums are personalized and can vary based on:

  • Age
  • Gender
  • ZIP code
  • Medicare Supplement plan letter
  • Tobacco use
  • Household-discount eligibility
  • Requested coverage date
  • The specific Humana underwriting company

A personalized rate comparison is necessary to determine the actual premium and value available to each applicant.

The Bottom Line

Humana Achieve may be a strong choice for someone seeking a competitively priced Medicare Supplement policy without paying for additional services that may go unused.

A standard Humana Medicare Supplement option that includes SilverSneakers may provide better overall value for someone who regularly uses a participating fitness center.

Humana is often competitively priced in Pennsylvania, but rates and company positions can change. The best approach is to compare the available Humana products with other Medicare Supplement companies using the applicant’s actual information.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Humana Achieve and Humana Medicare Supplement?

Humana Achieve is generally positioned as a lower-premium Medicare Supplement option and typically does not include SilverSneakers. Certain standard Humana Medicare Supplement policies may include SilverSneakers but may carry a different premium.

Is Humana Achieve a Medicare Supplement plan?

Yes. Humana Achieve is a Medicare Supplement policy that works alongside Original Medicare. It is not a Medicare Advantage plan.

Does Humana Achieve include SilverSneakers?

Humana Achieve generally does not include SilverSneakers. Applicants should confirm the benefits and additional services included with the particular policy before enrolling.

Does Humana Medicare Supplement include SilverSneakers?

Certain standard Humana Medicare Supplement policies may include SilverSneakers. Availability should be verified for the specific policy and applicant.

Is a Humana Medicare Supplement plan with SilverSneakers worth a higher premium?

It may be, particularly for someone who regularly uses a participating fitness center. Applicants should compare the difference in insurance premiums with what they would otherwise pay for a gym membership.

Does Humana always have the lowest Medicare Supplement rates?

No company always has the lowest Medicare Supplement rates for every applicant. Humana is often competitively priced, but premiums vary by applicant, location, selected plan and available discounts. Comparing multiple companies is the best way to determine which option provides the strongest overall value.

Are the medical benefits different?

When comparing the same Medicare Supplement plan letter, the standardized medical benefits are the same. SilverSneakers is an additional service and is not part of the standardized Medicare Supplement coverage.

Can I use any doctor with Humana Achieve?

You can generally use any doctor or hospital in the United States that accepts Medicare. Medicare Supplement policies do not use traditional provider networks.

Related Medicare Topics

Related Local Pages

Schedule Your Medicare Consultation Today

Medicare can be confusing, but getting answers shouldn’t be.

Whether you’re enrolling for the first time, reviewing your current coverage, considering a plan change, or simply looking for a second opinion, I’m happy to help you understand your options and answer your questions.

I’ve been helping Medicare beneficiaries since 1985, and I’ve built my practice on straightforward advice, long-term relationships, and treating people the way I’d want my own family treated.

If you’d like to discuss your Medicare options, call or text The DeAngelis Agency at 215-967-8828.

Click here to ask a question.

There’s no pressure and no obligation—just honest guidance to help you make a confident decision.

Call or Text 215-967-8828